Mondelēz to bear costs in wheat futures manipulation charge

CFTC takes civil action against Kraft and Mondelēz for wheat futures manipulation

The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) charged Mondelēz International and Kraft Foods for manipulation and attempted manipulation of the prices of cash wheat and wheat futures yesterday.

The civil complaint alleges that on five days in summer 2011 the companies - then a single entity - started a strategy to buy a six-month supply of wheat worth $90m, but never had the intention to take delivery of the wheat. Instead, the CFTC alleges the firms hoped the market would react to their huge long position by lowering cash wheat prices and strengthening the spread between December 2011 wheat and March 2012 wheat futures. Price shifts occurred and Mondelēz and Kraft earned over $5.4m in profit.

Aitan Goelman, the CFTC’s Director of Enforcement, said: “This case goes to the core of the CFTC’s mission: protecting market participants and the public from manipulation and abusive practices that undermine the integrity of the derivatives markets. A market participant who is not happy with cash prices available to it may not resort to manipulative trading strategies in an attempt to artificially lower that price.”

Kraft and Mondelēz are also accused of holding long positions on five days in December 2011 on wheat that exceeded the CBOT’s 600-contract speculative spot month position limit by as much as 2,110 contracts without having a valid hedge exemption in place or a bona fide need for that quantity of wheat.

From 2003 to January 2014, the firms are also allegedly conducted off-exchange futures transactions between two separate corporate trading accounts in violation of trading rules.

“In its continuing litigation against Kraft and Mondelēz, the CFTC seeks a permanent injunction from future violations of federal commodities laws, disgorgement, and civil monetary penalties,” said the CTFC in a release.

Kraft and Mondelēz response

In 2012, Mondelēz span off from Kraft to create a separate international snacks business. Kraft Foods Group was preserved as a North American grocery business.

Basil Maglaris, director of corporate affairs at Kraft Foods Group, said:  “While Kraft is named in CFTC the complaint, the transaction at issue occurred before our spin-off from Mondelēz International in October 2012, and it involved the business now owned and operated by Mondelēz or its affiliates.  The CFTC complaint primarily focuses on the trading of wheat futures contracts in December 2011.  More specifically, the type of wheat involved in the transaction is used in products such as cookies and crackers, which are not made by Kraft Foods Group.”

He said Mondelēz would therefore predominantly bear the cost of any penalties. “We do not expect this matter to have a financially material impact on Kraft,” said Maglaris.

Mondelēz refused to comment on active litigation, but said any fine issued by a court would not be material to investors.

The company said in a SEC filing before formal action was taken that it was cooperating with CFTC’s investigation. It said it expected to bear costs of any monetary penalties the CFTC may impose under a 2012 Separation and Distribution Agreement with Kraft.

Related News

The companies say they made "reasonable business decisions" in the face of an "uncertain market"

Mondelez and Kraft dismiss wheat manipulation charges

The EU has granted a record number of wheat export licenses for this season

EU wheat to maintain competitive edge over US

The belVita line will try to push forward the nutritious biscuit market in China

Mondelēz to bring belVita to China

J&J Snacks will have to pay up after allegedly failing to properly pay employees

J&J Snack Foods to pay $2.1m to temporary workers after federal investigation

Mondelēz accused of manipulating the wheat market in December 2011. Photo: iStock/DredK

Mondelēz loses bid to toss wheat manipulation suit

Canada is extending its requirements on grain volume movement for railways

Canada's minimum grain volume requirements, ConAgra Foods against child hunger, Wheat futures in Russia and Ukraine

The new quality criteria for wheat introduced a minimum 11% of protein content and Hagberg falling numbers at a minimum of 220 seconds, according to Reuters.

Wheat quality criteria, Carr’s Milling Industries, global grain surpluses, wheat production forecast

Top bakery, snack, cereal stories 2014

Top 12 stories of 2014: Frito-Lay marketing, snacking and wheat science

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.